Same recurring fee, very different practice —Concierge Medicine vs. Direct Primary Care
Both models ask patients to pay the practice directly for care and access. The differences that matter are the size of the fee, whether you keep billing insurance, and how many patients you can carry. Pick wrong and you either price yourself out of your market or build a panel you cannot serve.
- Lower fee
- DPC: more members, no claims for covered services
- Higher fee
- Concierge: fewer members, insurance often retained
- Same engine
- Both bill monthly, renew and need dunning
Where the two models actually differ
The fee and what it buys
DPC charges a modest monthly fee that covers defined primary-care services. Concierge charges a substantially higher retainer for enhanced access — extended appointments, direct physician contact, care coordination, sometimes an annual executive-style evaluation.
Insurance participation
This is the clearest dividing line. DPC practices generally stop billing insurance for the services the membership covers. Concierge practices commonly keep billing payers for the visits while the retainer covers access and non-reimbursable services.
Panel size and workload
DPC panels usually run in the hundreds, concierge panels smaller still. Both are a fraction of a traditional panel, and that reduction is the product — it is what makes same-day access and long visits possible.
Who your patients are
DPC sells on affordability and access, and pairs naturally with high-deductible plans and employer groups. Concierge sells on relationship and availability to patients willing to pay a premium. Market composition should decide this more than preference.
Compliance differences you cannot skip
Retainers billed alongside insurance raise questions DPC does not, especially where Medicare participation is involved, and several states regulate DPC agreements specifically. Whichever you pick, have the agreement and fee structure reviewed by counsel in your state.
How to decide
Start with the market, not the model
How many households near you will pay a premium retainer every month? If the honest answer is few, DPC economics fit better than concierge.
Model both at realistic panel sizes
Fee times members minus overhead, at the panel you can serve well rather than the maximum you can imagine. Run both models on the same spreadsheet before choosing.
Decide the insurance question deliberately
Dropping claims removes cost and complexity but removes a revenue floor too. Keeping them preserves the floor and keeps the billing overhead you were trying to escape.
Consider hybrid as a test, not a destination
Running a membership tier beside a traditional panel lets you prove demand before committing — as long as you accept that you are administering two revenue systems at once.
Practices That Got Off The Treadmill.
Select a practice to see how their membership revenue compounded month over month.
“We dropped two of our worst PPO contracts in year one. The membership plan replaced that revenue and then some — and we finally control our own fee schedule.”
- Members
- 612
- MRR
- $38.9K
- ARR
- $467K
- MRR Growth
- +284%
- Write-offs
- -$186K
Concierge vs. DPC questions
- What is the difference between concierge medicine and direct primary care?
- Concierge practices charge a higher retainer for enhanced access and commonly continue billing insurance for visits. DPC practices charge a lower monthly membership and generally stop billing insurance for the services the membership covers.
- Which is more profitable?
- Concierge earns more per member; DPC serves more members per physician and carries far less billing overhead. Profitability depends on the fee your market supports and the panel you can actually serve, so model both against your own numbers.
- Can I switch from concierge to DPC later?
- Yes, and practices do — usually by lowering the fee, dropping claims for covered services and growing the panel. Expect attrition through the transition and plan the messaging carefully.
- Do either of these replace a patient's insurance?
- No. Neither covers hospitalization, specialists or catastrophic care. Patients should keep separate coverage, and neither model should ever be marketed as insurance.
- Does the billing software differ between the two?
- No. Both need membership pricing, enrollment with payment credentials on file, automatic monthly charges, dunning, renewals and revenue reporting. The same system runs either model, and a hybrid practice needs it more than anyone.
Whichever model you pick, this is how you bill it
Price your memberships, enroll patients and employer groups on autopay, and track active members, churn and MRR in one place.
Own your revenue. Starting this month.
Launch a membership plan, enroll your uninsured patients, and watch recurring revenue land every month — no claims, no write-offs.
Free 30 days · Setup help included · Keep every member you enroll