How to Calculate the Impact of Going Fee for Service in Your Practice
If you have ever wondered how to calculate the impact of going fee for service, you’re in the right place, but buckle up—it’s going to be a bumpy ride for your status quo. Most dental practices are currently being suffocated by PPO providers. You feel it every morning when you look at your schedule and see a sea of “discounted” cleanings. You feel it when your overhead hits 75% because wage inflation is soaring while insurance reimbursements haven’t budged since the 90s.
In most practices we see, the owner is working harder than ever just to stay profitable. The real problem isn’t your clinical skill or your local competition; it’s your PPO dependency. Transitioning away from insurance relies on hard data, and understanding the financial shifts is the first step toward clinical and financial freedom.
How to Calculate the Impact of Going Fee for Service
Learn how to calculate the impact of going fee for service. Stop losing 40% to PPOs and discover the MRR power of dental membership plans today!
/how-to-calculate-the-impact-of-going-fee-for-service/
Are You Running a Dental Office or a Discount Charity? 💸
Typically, a dentist wants to earn more per patient, but they find themselves trapped in a “multi-sided market” where insurance companies own the patient and dictate the price. It’s a losing game. A common mistake is thinking that “volume” will save you. It won’t.
In our experience, trying to “out-drill” a 40% insurance write-off is like trying to empty the ocean with a leaky bucket. You’re exhausted, your team is burnt out, and your bank account doesn’t reflect the blood, sweat, and composite you put into those ops every day.
- Are you tired of “waiting” for reimbursements that barely cover your laboratory bills? 🦷
- Does it make sense to let a billion-dollar insurance company tell you what a crown is worth? 👑
- How much longer can your practice survive on 2002 fee schedules while paying 2025 wages? 📉
The solution isn’t just “dropping plans” and hoping for the best. That’s how you go out of business. The strategy is replacement. You need to replace that “dirty” insurance traffic with high-value, loyal membership patients using a tool like BoomCloud™.
The 40% Tax: How to Calculate the Impact of Going Fee for Service
Let’s talk math—the kind that moves the needle on your ARR (Annual Recurring Revenue). When you are in-network, you aren’t just giving a “small discount.” You are paying a massive tax for the privilege of the insurance company “sending” you patients they actually own.
To understand how to calculate the impact of going fee for service, you must start with a brutal look at your adjustments. In our experience, practices are often shocked to find they are writing off $300,000 to $600,000 a year. That is direct profit falling through the floorboards.
| Category | PPO Dependent Practice | Fee-for-Service + Membership |
|---|---|---|
| Average Reimbursed Fee | $800 (after 40% write-off) | $1,200 (Full Fee) |
| Patient Loyalty | Low (Goes where insurance says) | High (Committed to the Practice) |
| Case Acceptance | Low (Only does what “insurance covers”) | High (2X – 4X more spend) |
| Predictable Revenue | Zero (Dependent on claims) | Automated MRR (Monthly Recurring Revenue) |
Transition words often feel corporate, but let’s pivot to the truth: Membership patients spend 2X to 4X more than insurance patients. Why? Because they aren’t restricted by a “maximum” that was set in 1970. They have a direct relationship with you, rewarded by your membership plan. This dramatically improves your case acceptance rate.
Operator Insight: Moving to a Fee-for-Service Model
In our experience, most dentists fail at scaling a dental practice as a fee-for-service (FFS) model because they suffer from “The Fear.” They worry that if they drop Delta Dental, 50% of their patients will vanish overnight. This is a common concern related to patient retention problems.
A common mistake is “janking” the cord all at once. As Jordon Comstock discussed on the Automatic Patient Podcast with Dr. Dan Nelson, you shouldn’t just rip the band-aid off. You apply a “nicotine patch” first. That patch is your Dental Membership Plan. When you look at how to calculate the impact of going fee for service, you have to account for the retention power of these internal plans.
The real problem isn’t the insurance company; it’s that you haven’t given your patients a reason to stay that is stronger than their insurance card. When you create a membership program, you stop being a provider and start being a partner in their health. Software alone doesn’t solve this—strategy does.
Common Mistakes to Avoid:
- The “Letter” Mistake: Sending a cold, clinical letter saying “We no longer take your insurance.” (Use an empathy-based outreach instead!) ✉️
- No Parachute: Dropping a major PPO without having at least 200–300 members already on your internal plan. 🪱 This ties into how to prevent cancellations in the dental office by building loyalty.
- Ignoring the Team: If your front desk doesn’t believe in the plan, they won’t sell it. You must incentivize them to grow your MRR. 🏆
The Epiphany: How to Calculate the Impact of Going Fee for Service on Practice Value
I want you to imagine a Friday afternoon. You’re exhausted, but instead of worrying about the stack of unpaid claims on your desk, you look at your dashboard. You see that $25,000 was just deposited into your account automatically. No claims. No denials. No “Blue Cross” paperwork.
That is the power of Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR). When you emphasize MRR and ARR, you change the valuation of your practice. Scaling a dental practice becomes predictable. You aren’t hunting for new patients every month; you are harvesting the loyalty of the ones you already have. This is a crucial metric when learning how to calculate the impact of going fee for service.
Membership patients are the “Goldilocks” of your practice. They show up, they say “yes” to treatment, and they pay your full fee because the membership makes it accessible. This is the best way to grow a practice: Optimize revenue per patient.
Case Study: Dr. “No More Discounts” (A BoomCloud™ Story) 🚀
Let’s look at a practice in Idaho that decided they were done with the PPO grind. They practiced in a high-overhead area and were getting “choked out” by stagnant reimbursements. They started their membership plan while still in-network to build their “parachute.”
| Metric | Month 1 (Awareness) | Month 24 (FFS Transition) |
|---|---|---|
| Member Count | 12 | 845 |
| Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) | $420 | $29,575 |
| Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR) | $5,040 | $354,900 |
| Insurance Write-offs | $42,000/mo | $4,500/mo (Remaining specialty plans) |
The impact: By the time they dropped their biggest PPO (the “Evil Empire”), they already had enough ARR to cover their entire building lease and half their payroll. That’s the real-world result of knowing how to calculate the impact of going fee for service with courage. This demonstrates excellent DSO growth principles by creating predictable revenue.
From Experience: The Financial Impact Breakdown
Let’s get granular. If you have 1,000 active patients and 500 are on a PPO where you write off 40% of a $1,000 case, you are losing $400 every time that patient sits in the chair. In most practices we see, that adds up to roughly $20,000 per month in “lost” profit. Consider this the opposite of effective new patient marketing, as it’s about retaining and maximizing value from existing ones.
If you move just 250 of those patients to a $35/month membership plan:
1. You generate $8,750 in MRR ($105,000/year ARR).
2. You stop writing off 40% on their restorative work.
3. Those 250 patients now spend 2.5X more on elective dentistry like whitening or clear aligners because they feel like “members” of an exclusive club.
Total swing in practice value? Easily $250,000+ in annual profit. This isn’t just about “earning more”; it’s about reclaiming the value of your education and your time.
Strategies for Fee-for-Service Dental Practice Growth
Typically, the transition involves three phases. First, you must identify your “Avatar” (who we call FRED). FRED is the patient who values your time, your health-centered approach, and isn’t just looking for the “cheapest” cleaning in town. Assessing your current patient mix is vital when determining how to calculate the impact of going fee for service.
Second, use data. Tools like Dental Intelligence can help you see which plans are hurting you the most. Third, automate the loyalty. You cannot manage a 500-member plan on an Excel spreadsheet. You will fail. You need an automated engine like BoomCloud™ to handle the billing, the tracking, and the renewals. This can be found in sophisticated dental appointment scheduling software systems.
The impact of eliminating dental insurance on practice revenue is almost always positive if you replace the “unrestricted” patient flow with a “controlled” membership flow. You aren’t just a dentist anymore; you’re the owner of a subscription-based healthcare model. 🏢
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my practice is ready to go fee-for-service?
You are ready when your overhead is high, your “write-offs” exceed your actual take-home pay, and you have a solid patient base that trusts the clinical outcomes you provide. If you have at least 15–20% of your patients asking for “no insurance” options, the door is wide open. Many dental practice statistics support this trend.
Will I lose patients if I move to fee-for-service dentistry?
In most practices we see, you will lose about 10–15% of the “insurance-only” patients. However, you replace them with higher-paying patients and significantly reduce your overhead, meaning you often make more money while seeing fewer people.
What is the role of a membership plan in an FFS transition?
The membership plan acts as the “bridge.” It gives patients who lose their “in-network” status a reason to stay. It mimics the “benefits” of insurance without the middleman, allowing you to capture the full value of the treatment while giving the patient a fair, transparent price.
Calculate Your Opportunity Today
Stop being a slave to the PPO fee schedule. You didn’t go to dental school for eight years to be told what you’re worth by a cubicle-dweller at an insurance company. It’s time to take control of your revenue per patient and build the practice of your dreams. Perhaps even explore some funny dental ads to lighten the mood during your transition!
Understanding how to calculate the impact of going fee for service isn’t just about the “risk”—it’s about the risk of staying dependent on declining PPO rates. Use the data, trust the process, and let BoomCloud™ build your parachute while you take the leap toward freedom. Effective internet dental marketing, combined with strategic transition planning, is key.
Ready to see the math for your specific practice?
👉 Schedule a Demo of BoomCloud™ & Learn how to manage & grow your membership plan here.
👉 Download the Million-Dollar Membership Plan Ebook.
