How to Write an Appeal Letter for Dental Insurance Denial (and Never Beg Again): 7 Bold Moves to Get Paid & Escape the PPO Trap

June 08, 2025
Topics: Dental
Written by: Lisa Rasmussen

How Smart Practice Owners Are Ditching PPOs and Adding $500K+ in Recurring Revenue

Join our exclusive course and discover the proven strategies that practices use to add $10,000+ in monthly recurring revenue with patient membership plans. Dr. Evans took this course and now has over 800 members and $37,000/mo of predictable recurring revenue. Watch this webinar before we take it down in 24 hours.

This course normally sells for $297.

But right now, I’m giving you access for just $47.

That’s cheaper than a hygiene cleaning.

And it could be the most profitable $47 you ever spend.

Get the Course Here → The Six-Figure Membership Plan Course

What You Will Learn:

- How to Build a Membership Plan That Pays You Monthly (Even While You Sleep!)

- Why PPOs Are Stealing Your Revenue—And How to Take Control of Your Profits

- The 3-Step System to Scale Recurring Revenue
(Even If You’ve Never Sold a Membership Plan Before!)

- The #1 Mistake Dentists Make When Dropping PPOs (And How to Avoid It!)

LIVE Case Study: How One Dentist Went from PPO-Dependent to $500K+/Year in Recurring Revenue With a Membership Program!

In dentistry today, PPOs are not your friend, they hurt your cash flow, demolish your profit margins, jeopardize your patient relationships & use A.I. to deny claims!!

If I had an employee or partner that messed up my business like that, I would FIRE them ASAP! 

$47. No fluff. Just results.

You in?

Dental Insurance Just Denied You Again? Time to Flip the Script

How to write an appeal letter for dental insurance denial. You did the work. Billed it right. Sent in the X-rays.
And what did you get? A cold, boring letter saying: DENIED.

Welcome to the wild world of dental insurance — where you provide top-tier care, and some mystery man in a cubicle 500 miles away says, “Yeah… we’re not paying for that.”

Writing an appeal letter for dental insurance denial shouldn’t feel like a hostage negotiation.

But here’s the kicker: While you’re fighting for $300 reimbursement, some practices are skipping the insurance circus altogether and building predictable, scalable recurring revenue with membership plans.

Let’s go deep — we’ll show you how to fight (and win) the insurance battle when you need to. Then we’ll show you how to ditch it entirely using BoomCloud™.


Story: The Office That Said “Enough!” to Denials

Enter: Dr. Jason, Houston-based general dentist with a busy practice and a hate-hate relationship with PPOs.

He had:

  • $67,000 in denied claims in 2022

  • A full-time staff member doing nothing but appeals

  • A daily “WTF” moment reading EOBs

So, he learned how to write iron-clad appeal letters. But more importantly — he realized fighting for pennies wasn’t a growth plan.

Enter: BoomCloud™.

He launched a membership plan and started offering patients a way around the insurance mess:

  • $25/month plans

  • 2 cleanings, exams, discounts

  • Zero denials, zero headaches

6 months later:

  • 390 members

  • $9,750/month in MRR

  • $117,000/year in ARR

  • A 3.2X increase in revenue per patient

Now his team still writes appeals — but way fewer. And way better. The rest? Straight cash, no middlemen.


Win the Appeal War, Then Exit the Battle

If you’re asking how to write an appeal letter for dental insurance denial, you’re in one of two camps:

  1. Trying to recover lost revenue

  2. Looking for a long-term escape plan

Here’s the game plan:

✅ Win more appeals with a bulletproof template
✅ Use BoomCloud™ to convert those patients into paying members
✅ Grow MRR + ARR and reduce your PPO dependence

Want to see how? BoomCloudApps.com


From Denials to Recurring Revenue

Dr. Jason told us:

“We used to react to every insurance denial like a 5-alarm fire. Now we just say, ‘We’ve got another option that doesn’t involve the games.’ Patients love it. And our bank account does too.”

The big “aha” wasn’t about writing better letters — it was realizing that insurance isn’t the goal.

Revenue is. Loyalty is. Predictability is.


How to Write an Appeal Letter for Dental Insurance Denial That Doesn’t Get Ignored

Here’s your no-BS, no-begging-needed playbook


️ Step 1: Use a Strong Subject Line

They get hundreds a day. Make yours count:

  • “Urgent Appeal – Patient ID [#] – Medical Necessity for [Procedure]”

  • “Reconsideration Request – Clinical Justification Attached”


Step 2: Include All Required Documentation

Checklist:

  • Copy of the original claim

  • Denial notice

  • Clinical notes

  • X-rays or imaging

  • Letter of medical necessity

  • CDT code and rationale


Step 3: Write a Convincing Cover Letter

Use clear, professional language — but with fire. Don’t be afraid to advocate HARD.

Sample Template:

To Whom It May Concern,
We are appealing the denial of coverage for [Procedure] for [Patient Name, DOB].
This treatment is medically necessary based on [clinical reasoning + patient symptoms].
The CDT Code [#] applies as per ADA guidelines. Attached are clinical notes and diagnostics to support this appeal.

We request immediate reconsideration and approval for reimbursement.

Regards,
[Your Name & Title]


Step 4: Follow Up Like a Boss

Insurance companies bet on you not following up.

✅ Set a calendar reminder
✅ Call 7–10 business days after submission
✅ Ask for a supervisor if needed
✅ Document everything (dates, names, response)


Pro Tip: Don’t Just Appeal… Upsell Memberships

Every denial is a moment to say:
“Insurance isn’t working — but we are. Let’s sign you up for our membership program.”

BoomCloud™ helps you:

  • Auto-enroll patients

  • Collect payments

  • Offer instant discounts

  • Avoid denials entirely


Why Membership Plans Beat Denials Every Time

Real data from BoomCloud™ users:

  • Revenue per member patient = $2,700/year

  • Revenue per insurance patient = $800–$1,200/year

  • Member treatment acceptance rate = 62–74%

  • Insurance patient acceptance = 35–42%

Membership isn’t just an alternative — it’s an upgrade


Appeal Letter Success Checklist

✅ Clear subject line
✅ Detailed patient info
✅ Justification using CDT codes
✅ Attach clinical proof
✅ Strong call to action
✅ Date and deadline for response
✅ Follow-up plan
✅ Offer membership alternative with BoomCloud™


Bonus: Use Denial Data to Power Membership Sales

Turn lemons into leads ➡️

When a claim gets denied:

  • Trigger an automated BoomCloud™ email: “Insurance denied again? Here’s how we can help.”

  • Offer discounted first month for switching to membership

  • Track conversion rates directly in BoomCloud™

Because sometimes the best way to win the game… is to stop playing it


FAQs

How long do I have to file an appeal?
Most insurers give you 30–60 days. Act fast and document everything.

Can patients write appeal letters themselves?
Yes! In fact, it’s powerful to include both provider and patient letters.

What if I lose the appeal?
Use it as an upsell moment for membership. “No more denials when you go direct.”

Is BoomCloud™ HIPAA-compliant?
100%. Plus it integrates with most PMS systems and makes admin a breeze.

Do patients actually like membership plans?
They LOVE them. More value, fewer surprises, and actual care without red tape.


Final Thoughts: Deny the Denials, Own the Revenue

Learning how to write an appeal letter for dental insurance denial is crucial.
But building a practice that doesn’t depend on denials? That’s next level.

BoomCloud™ helps you:

  • Fight fewer insurance battles

  • Win more loyal patients

  • Build rock-solid MRR & ARR

  • Maximize revenue per patient

No middlemen. No red tape. Just direct, powerful, profitable care.

Want to spend less time chasing money and more time changing lives?
Visit https://www.boomcloudapps.com


Inbound Link Suggestions:

  • Link to “How to Build a Dental Membership Program”

  • Link to “Top Dental Billing Mistakes and Fixes”

  • Link to “Dental Insurance FAQs for Staff”

Outbound Link Suggestions:


My Top Podcasts

How Smart Practice Owners Attract, Retain & Create Recurring Revenue

Get the book that’s helping over 65,000  practices ditch insurance, boost cash flow, and create financial freedom with a patient membership program.

Membership Plans For Optometrists

vision-membership-plan-ebook Creating a patient membership plan is the smartest strategy to implement in your practice. You will increase patient satisfaction & loyalty, Increase predictable recurring revenue & increase sales!

Fire The PPOs!

Say goodbye to PPOs and hello to a thriving, independent dental practice. Don’t miss out – your journey to financial freedom starts here!

Subscribe to Our Podcasts!

Jordon Comstock

Author Bio

Jordon Comstock is the Founder & CEO of BoomCloud™, a software that allows practice, clinic & spa owners to build, manage and scale a membership program. This helps practice & clinic owners to create recurring revenue & improve loyalty via membership programs. Jordon is passionate about Music, Hawaii, Healthcare businesses like: dentistry, optometry, med spas and massage spas. Schedule a demo of BoomCloud™ and learn how membership programs can improve your business. Here are more dental books to improve your practice

Calculate Your Potential

with BoomCloud™

Recurring Revenue Growth Calculator

Discover the revenue potential of your practice’s membership plans. This calculator helps you project growth by analyzing key factors like patient volume, plan pricing, and service utilization. See how implementing a custom plan can boost your bottom line.

Revenue Calculator

 PPO Loss Calculator – How Much are YOU Losing?

Calculate the hidden costs of relying on traditional PPO plans. Our PPO Loss Calculator reveals the revenue you could be missing out on and helps you strategize for greater profitability with a membership-based model.

PPO Loss Calculator